Boba Fett’s Book gives fans of the galaxy’s most notorious bounty hunter a glimpse into his life from falling into the jaws of the Sarlacc to Return of the Jedi and usurping Jabba the Hutt as Tatooine’s new crime lord during the events of The Mandalorian, and despite the highlighting of one of the star wars most mysterious characters in the franchise, the Disney+ series remains controversial.
To consider it as a series superior to The Mandalorian to think that some of its worst aspects are some of its most winning accomplishments, fans have taken to Reddit to voice their unpopular opinions on the show, proving that no matter how divisive the show is, the fandom is more excited than Grogu surrounded by floating frogs.
Robert Rodriguez Directed Episodes Aren’t That Bad
Robert Rodriguez is a highly regarded director whose films (El Mariachi, Desperado) have earned him a cult following, but many star wars fans don’t think he was the right creative mind to direct episodes of Boba Fett’s Book with what james_hamilton1234 calls “janky shots”.
Tastentier thinks that “a director should only be criticized for things that are really his responsibility”, and since Rodriguez hasn’t written much material featuring the much maligned cyberpunk mods (Jon Favreau has) and others, it shouldn’t receive criticism, and that the Season 1 finale was “masterfully executed”.
It has too many famous people
Unlike Din Djarin, Boba Fett is a character linked to several of the most famous faces in the star wars Universe dating back to the original trilogy. Most fans appreciate seeing him connected in some way to other recognizable characters from the franchise – such as Luke Skywalker – if only to fit his story into the bigger picture in the galaxy. .
PortugeseZebra thinks there are already too many cameos in the series with “Luke, Ahsoka, Grogu, Cobb Vanth and Cad Bane and we had a whole Mando-centric episode”. While some fans may agree that it “diverts the focus from Boba Fett”, for the majority, like the whiskyclouds “it’s not cameos if they’re world building”.
Temuera Morrison is too old for the role
While Boba Fett should be somewhere in his 40s by the time Boba Fett’s Book takes place, its time being digested in the Sarlacc’s stomach would certainly warrant degenerative effects. Temuera Morrison, the actor who played Jango Fett in Star Wars: Episode II – Attack of the Clones is 61, but is still considered fit enough to convincingly portray the brutal bounty hunter.
“I love his acting in general,” says addys, “but in the physical action scenes, it’s painfully obvious that he’s about a guy over 60 trying to ‘sell ‘ action moves from a much younger character.” JangoFettDidNoWrong disagrees, citing that “he’s in better shape than most 20-year-old Star Wars fans who constantly insult him.” Indeed, an interview with The Project in which Morrison proudly displays the gym he used backstage during filming clearly shows his dedication to the physicality of the role.
Mods add variety
Seeing the shiny, shiny speeder bikes driven by the mods amid the gritty, barren landscape of Tatooine was considered shocking in Episode 3, with fans like undercoveryankee responding to the kaleidoscopic biker gang by claiming that “Tatooine has always been portrayed like a tough place on mechanical things.”
WhiskersCleveland took a different approach, pointing out that “in so many shows, all biker gangs and just gangs in general are all basically the same. Usually dark clothes, sunglasses, tattoos, etc. We finally get a different style (clearly based on Mod culture) where everything is bright and shiny and very personalized.” The mod rides may seem more at home on a Core planet like Coruscant, but they certainly add to the uniqueness of the series.
Boba don’t act like Boba is the way
For many fans to see Boba Fett’s metamorphosis from a “ruthless killer” to a family-oriented crime lord and genuinely likeable character in Boba Fett’s Book was unsettling, especially given the importance he placed on protecting his community rather than seeking out himself as he had done during his tenure as the galaxy’s most feared bounty hunter.
“As the star of his own show, he has to play a totally different role. A protagonist,” explained nudeldifudel, pointing out that the show’s format required Boba Fett to evolve from villain to Return of the Jedi as a hero after The Mandalorian. While that might sound unusual, it adds dimension to a character who had a life-altering experience that, at least in canon, has remained two-dimensional and shrouded in mystery and myth.
Boba Fett’s book is better than The Mandalorian
More star wars fans are watching The Mandalorian as one of the best things to emerge since Disney bought Lucasfilm, and since it also features a monosyllabic beskar-clad warrior, fans inevitably compare it to Boba Fett’s Book and determine its superior product due to issues with pacing, plot, and overall structure.
“The Mandalorian had no plot, no character development, no plot points on any of the episodes,” Jonwondon claims, calling it “pure eye candy in the Star Wars universe.” It’s rare for a spin-off to surpass its predecessor, but for some fans, Boba Fett’s Book has more meaning behind it since it features a previously selfish character who deliberately makes changes to better his life and those around him.
Cad Bane’s death was perfect
Cad Bane was one of the most popular new characters in the star wars canon for several years, at the origin of animated series like clone wars as Boba Fett’s mentor, and later appearing in The bad lot as a cunning opponent of rogue clone troopers. His apparent death at the end of Boba Fett’s Book The season finale left many fans outraged.
“Cad Bane’s death in the last episode was my favorite part,” says minimis_jeff, “I thought it was perfect how they did it.” They allude to Fett killing Bane with the gaffi stick, a symbol of the new path granted to him by his time among the Tuskens, but for some fans it was too quick and easy a death for one of the most infamous. galaxy gunslingers.
Boba Fett’s book is awesome
Given the immense anticipation surrounding the series, Boba Fett’s Book to be good and satisfy every fan’s desires was almost impossible. It portrayed a character loved by star wars fans for decades, and could only hope to cement a legacy of being admired by some for its subversive qualities and reviled by others for its radical departure from established tradition.
Some fans like ivrestuporr “have no idea why the show is hated,” continuing to give “kudos to Favreau and Filoni for literally saving Star Wars.” [because] they are true Star Wars fans with a great understanding of lore, themes and audience.” This may not be the Boba Fett story all fans want, but some fans are just grateful have a Boba Fett story.
The fight is corny
Boba Fett’s Book might seem slow, but it’s packed with plenty of intense action sequences and brawls featuring Boba Fett specifically going up against everyone from the Pyke Syndicate to the Nikto Sandrunners. One unpopular opinion that keeps resurfacing focuses on the sequences featuring Temuera Morrison, which many fans consider to be the best in a series considered inconsistent at best.
“I feel like a lot of the fights on the show are corny,” says TheChosenCupcake, adding “a lot of the scenes in general are corny. [and] It doesn’t help that the Boba actor (Temuera Morrison) does a lot of those weird, exaggerated faces.” Most fans agree that while Temuera Morrison may be pushing the limits of his physique at over 60, the addition of his Maori Heritage in Boba Fett’s Book with “Pukana warfaces / traditional warfaces” (as stated by JangoDidNoWrong) during his fight scenes only add to the mystique of his character.
Boba Fett was never a big bad and had no depth
While fans have been busy complaining that Boba Fett’s characterization under Disney castrated a once great antagonist, a few like kwan_e argue that “Boba Fett was never one of the ‘greatest villains.’ [because] it had virtually no screen time in the original trilogy and then was cast in the Sarlacc.”
HailCaesar252 acknowledges, “Well, as a fan of the character, you will be blamed for that opinion. And in some ways, our expectations for Boba are our fault.” Due to the fact that Boba Fett has very little story in the original trilogy, the creative team at Disney has been free to expand his story in a direction that defies the expectations of fans who have had decades of material from the movie. Expanded Universe to crystallize a particular image of him that leaves little room. room for further development.
NEXT: Every Western Movie Referenced In Boba Fett’s Book
Peacemaker forgot to answer a major mystery
About the Author